| PHIL 460.001/660.001
The Self Dr. Deborah Achtenberg |
Spring 2001
11:00 - 12:15pm Tues., Thurs. |
THE SELF: PHILOSOPHIC AND
PSYCHOANALYTIC EXPLORATIONS
(A GENERAL CAPSTONE COURSE)
COURSE OUTLINE
Introduction (approx. 1 class)
PART I: THE SEPARATE SELF
Immanuel Kant
"The Doctrine of Virtue” (1797)
(approx. 3 classes)
(1724-1804)
Preface, Introduction (pp. 181-213)
Part I: Duties to Oneself (pp. 214-242)
Part II: Duties of Virtue to Others (pp. 243-280)
Sigmund Freud
Five Lectures on Psychoanalysis (1909)
(approx. 6 classes)
(1856-1939)
"Fräulein Anna O. (Breuer)" (1893)
Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality
(1905)
"Two Principles in Mental Functioning"
(1911), "A Note on the Unconscious in
Psychoanalysis" (1912), “On Narcissism"
(1914), "Instincts and their Vicissitudes"
(1915), “Repression” (1915)
"Mourning and Melancholia" (1917),
"Group Psychology and the Analysis
of the Ego” (1921, sections VII-XI),
"The Libido Theory" (1923)
"The Ego and the Id" (1923,
sections II-V),"The Passing of the
Oedipus Complex" (1924) "Neurosis
and Psychosis" (1924), "The Economic
Problem in Masochism" (1924)
PART II: THE AUTHENTIC SELF
Ralph Waldo Emerson
"Self-Reliance," “Friendship”
(approx. 2 classes)
(1803-1882)
(1841)
D.W. Winnicott
"The Capacity to be Alone” (1958)
(approx. 3 classes)
(1896-1971)
"The Theory of the Parent-Infant
Relationship"(1960), "Ego Integration
in Child Development" (1962), "From
Dependence towards Independence in
the Development of the Individual"
(1963)
"Ego Distortion in Terms of True and
False Self" (1960), "Living Creatively"
(1970)
"The Capacity for Concern" (1963),
"Transitional Objects and Transi-
tional Phenomena: A Study of the
First Not-Me Possession" (1951)
Midterm Examination (1 class)
PART III: THE INTERDEPENDENT SELF
G.W.F. Hegel
"Self-Consciousness: Lordship
(approx. 3 classes)
(1770-1831)
and Bondage; Stoicism, Scepticism,
and the Unhappy Consciousness (from
The Phenomenology of Spirit, 1807)
Marie Cardinal
The Words to Say It (1983)
(approx. 2 classes)
(1929- )
Margaret Mahler
N. Gregory Hamilton
(approx. 2 classes)
(1897-1985)
Self and Others: Object Relations
Theory in Practice (1988)
Salvador Minuchin
Family Healing: Tales of Hope and (approx. 2 classes)
Renewal from Family Therapy (1993)
PART IV: THE PERFORMATIVE SELF
Muriel Dimen
"Strange Hearts: On the Paradoxical
(approx. 1 class)
Liaison between Psychoanalysis
and Feminism" (1998)
Judith Butler
Gender Trouble: Feminism and
(approx. 3 classes)
the Subversion of Identity (1990)
Nancy Chodorow
"Heterosexuality as a Compromise
(approx. 1 class)
Formation" (1992)
Minnie Bruce Pratt
S/HE (selections) (1995)
(approx. 1 class)
COURSE TOPIC: the self
COURSE GOALS: increased understanding of the course topic; increased self-awareness
COURSE TEXTS: The texts are available from the university bookstore unless otherwise noted:
PART I:
Immanuel Kant, The Metaphysics of Morals (Cambridge)
Sigmund Freud, Five Lectures on Psychoanalysis (Norton)
--------, "Fräulein Anna O. (Breuer)" (1893)
(This reading will be on file for student use in the Department of
Philosophy office and at the reserve desk in Getchell Library.)
--------, Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality (Basic Books)
--------, General Psychological Theory (Collier Books)
(Includes all the Freud selections not listed here.)
--------, "Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego" (1921, sections
VII-XI), "The Ego and the Id" (sections II-V,
1923),"The Passing of the Oedipus Complex" (1924)
(These three essays will be on file.)
Part II:
Ralph Waldo Emerson, "Self-Reliance," "Friendship" (1841)
(The essays will be on file. For students who wish to do further
reading of Emerson's essays, The Essays of Ralph Waldo Emerson (Harvard
U. Press, Belknap) is available for purchase at the University Bookstore.)
D.W. Winnicott, The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment:
Studies in the Theory of Emotional Development (International Universities
Press)
(Includes: "The Capacity to Be Alone," "The Theory of the Parent-Infant
Relationship," "Ego Integration in Child Development," "From Dependence
towards Independence in the Develop~ment of the Individual," "Ego Distortion
in Terms of True and False Self.")
(This book is available from the university bookstore. The essays will be on file.)
"Living Creatively," "The Capacity for Concern," "Transi~tional Objects
and Transitional Phenomena: A Study of the First Not-Me Possession."
(Essays will be on file.)
Part III:
Selections G.W.F. Hegel, Phenomenology of Spirit (Oxford University
Press) ("Self-Consciousness: The Truth of Self-Certainty: Independence
and dependence of self-consciousness: Lordship and Bondage; Freedom
of self-consciousness: Stoicism, Scepticism, and the Unhappy Consciousness)
(The selections will be on file. For students who wish to read
more of Hegel's Phenomenology, it is available for purchase from the University
bookstore.)
Marie Cardinal, The Words to Say It (Van Vactor and Goodheart)
N. Gregory Hamilton, Self and Others: Object Relations Theory
in Practice (Jason Aronson, Inc.)
(To understand Margaret Mahler's object relations theory, we will read
and talk about this clinical textbook dealing primarily with Mahlerian
object relations theory.)
Part IV
Muriel Dimen, “Strange Hearts: On the Paradoxical Liaison between
Psychoanalysis and Feminism.”
(The essay will be on file.)
Judith Butler, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (Routledge)
Nancy Chodorow, “Heterosexuality as a Compromise Formation.”
(The essay will be on file.)
Minnie Bruce Pratt, S/HE (selections)
(The selections will be on file.)
CAPSTONE REQUIREMENTS: Every capstone course meets the
following requirements:
1. It builds upon the core curriculum, providing the opportunity
for students to bring to bear knowledge gained in core courses
and knowledge derived from major and elective
courses.
2. It is integrative, broadly focussed, multi-disciplinary, and,
if relevant and feasible, cross-cultural.
3. It focuses on ethical and substantive issues, problems and
themes that affect the world community and broad cross-sections
of humankind.
4. It encourages or promotes critical and analytic thinking,
reaching
beyond traditional or orthodox approaches and
perspectives; it challenges students to question
and critically examine established assumptions and paradigms.
5. It includes a rigorous writing component and also, whenever
possible, a computational component.
COURSE REQUIREMENTS (UNDERGRADUATE):
Readings as assigned
Participation in class discussion
Class attendance
Two take-home written assignments
Two papers (approx. 8 pp.)
Midterm examination
Final examination (Thurs., May 10, 7:30-9:30am)
TAKE-HOME ASSIGNMENTS: The format and dates for take-home written assignments will be announced. The purpose of the assignments is to help students with their reading.
PAPERS: The papers will be essays (not research papers). They will be around eight pages long. Due dates for papers will be announced.
You need use no books other than the course texts to write the papers. In an essay, you state a thesis, explain it and argue for it. The basic structure of an essay is: an introduction in which you state your thesis, the body of the essay in which you explain and argue for your thesis, the conclusion in which you summarize or highlight what you have done in the essay.
Essays will be typed or word processed, double-spaced and in ten or twelve point type. They will have a title and a title page. The pages will be numbered. There will be no extra spaces between paragraphs. They will be in finished form and without errors in grammar, spelling and punctuation. All quotations will be accompanied by a reference in parentheses. The format for references will be explained in class.
Essays will be evaluated on the following basis:
1. Do you have the parts mentioned above (introduction, body,
conclusion)?
2. Do you fulfill the functions mentioned above (state thesis,
explain it, argue for it, summarize or highlight)?
3. Is the thesis you are writing about an interesting and important
one?
4. Does your explanation of the thesis show that it is an interesting
and important one? Does your explanation make the basic
concepts and terms in your essay clear to
the reader?
5. Are your arguments clear and convincing to the reader?
6. Do you use specific examples from the text you are writing
about to make your arguments stronger? Do you use direct
quotations from the text you are writing about
to make your arguments stronger?
7. Does your conclusion add something to the essay as a whole?
8. Is the essay typed or word processed, double-spaced and in
ten or twelve point type? Does it include a title and a title
page? Are the pages numbered?
Does the essay have no extra space between paragraphs? Is it in finished
form and
without errors in grammar, spelling and punctuation?
Are all quotations accompanied by a reference in parentheses?
EXAMINATIONS: The examinations will have two sections, an informational section and an essay section, each worth 50 points. The mid-term examination will be held after completion of our discussion of D.W. Winnicott (probably early March). The final examination will be Thursday, May 10, from 7:30 to 9:30am.
EVALUATION: Grades will be based on the take-home assignments, papers and examinations, weighted equally (1/3 each). Excellent class participation may raise your grade somewhat over the mathematical average, at the discretion of the instructor.
Late papers and take-home assignments will lose a letter grade for each class session they are late. There are no make-up examinations except in the case of illness or emergency.
The grading scale is: 94-100, A; 90-93 A-; 87-89 B+; 84-86 B; 80-83 B-; 77-79 C+; 74-76 C; 70-73 C-; 67-69 D+; 64-66 D; 60-63 D-; below 60, F.
It is the instructor's policy that cheating, plagiarism or submission of written work for this course which was submitted in another course merits a course grade of 'F'.
CLASS FORMAT: The class will be a combination of lecture and discussion. The discussion will be, generally, guided discussion rather than general discussion or general debate.
Lectures and discussions will refer to course texts. Students will need to bring the relevant course texts to class if they are to benefit from lectures and discussions.
ATTENDANCE: Much of the important work in this course goes on in class. Students are expected to be in attendance except in cases of illness or emergency. Students are expected not to make appointments that conflict with class sessions.
STUDYING: Many students will find that they do better work in this course if they study together with other students.
GRADUATE STUDENTS:
This course is a 400-level undergraduate course offered also for graduate-level
credit. To receive graduate-level credit, students will fulfill some
requirements that are the same as the requirements for undergraduate students,
namely: readings as assigned, participation in class discussion,
class attendance, two take-home written assignments, two papers, two examinations.
Graduate students will also fulfill some requirements that are different than the requirements for undergraduate students, namely: their papers will be longer (15 pp.); their papers will derive from some additional reading on a topic of mutual interest to the student and the instructor to be selected in consultation with the instructor; graduate students will meet with the instructor to discuss the additional readings and the papers before beginning work on the papers.
Graduate students will meet the same evaluation criteria as undergraduate students and some additional criteria, namely: Do the papers evidently derive from additional reading? Does the student’s writing reflect broad familiarity with philosophic concepts and modes of argumentation? Does the student’s writing reflect some understanding of the history of philosophic treatment of the concepts discussed? Is the student able to sustain multifaceted argument and analysis?
Graduate students will achieve deeper understanding of the course material as a result of their additional reading and of their discussions with the instructor. Graduate students will meet with the instructor towards the beginning of the semester to discuss and additional readings and meetings with the instructor at a time of mutual convenience.
DISABILITY POLICY: The Department of Philosophy is committed to equal opportunity in education for all students, including those with documented physical or learning disabilities. According to University policy, a student with a documented disability is required to contact his or her instructors during the first week of each semester to discuss accommodations appropriate to ensure equity in grading, classroom experiences and out-of-class assignments. Each instructor will meet with the student and Student Services Center staff members to formulate a written plan for appropriate accommodations, if they are required.
* * *
My office hours are Tuesdays, 2:00 - 4:00pm (108D Cain Hall), or by appointment. Please feel free to come by to discuss the course topics or your progress in the course. I am happy to meet with you at some other time if it is more convenient. If you wish to make an appointment to see me at some other time, call: 784-6742, -6846.
If you try to get in touch with me and cannot, leave a note with your
phone number so that I can call you.